People
The New Party News

News from the New Party

Thursday, January 25, 2007

Raising the white flag

It is hard to disagree with Iain Dale's comment regarding the Liberal Democrats' call for a phased withdrawal of British forces from Iraq by October:
I have to say this is one of the most irresponsible policy announcements I have heard from them for a long time - and that's saying something. It sends all the wrong signals to those in Iraq who rely on British troops to keep the peace and undermines their authority. Naturally we should be arguing for a phased withdrawal when the job is complete, but it is impossible to argue that our mission in Iraq has been completed - or is anywhere near being completed. Now is not the time to make publicity seeking gestures.

...If we pull out now we will exacerbate the danger of a full scale civil war. If that cannot be described as 'irresponsible' I don't know what would. The 'mission' I refer to above is to gradually restore order and bring about a situation where people can safely go about their business and the Iraqi Police and security forces are capable of keeping the peace. That point has not arrived. When it does, no one will be happier than me. To say we should pull out in a matter of months leaving the Iraqis to their own devices is the equivalent of moral cowardice. Whatever one thought of the reasons for invading the country in the first place, we are where we are.
Similar sentiments to those expressed by the Liberal Democrats were uttered by Plaid Cymru MP Elfyn Llwyd on BBC News 24 TV. Since Elfyn Llwyd cannot imagine that the situation in Iraq can be any worse than it is at the moment, there is nothing to be gained by leaving British forces in Iraq. They should be brought home, the argument goes, and innocent Iraqi civilians should be left to their own devices regardless. What is staggering about this kind of "logic" is that the people who spout it like to imagine that they are claiming the moral high ground. If this is morality at all, then it is morality for the Big Brother generation. This is a war fought thousands of miles away, which most of our citizens encounter only on television and which is fought for a cause which too many of our citizens (and far too many of our politicians) cannot be bothered to try to understand. The people of Iraq, and for that matter British service personnel, deserve better.